Button-Up vs. Button-Down Shirts: Understanding Differences, History, Style & When to Wear

Difference Between Button Up vs Button Down Shirts

Men’s shirts are that one garment that never runs out of fashion; these are always in vogue. All that changes are the seasons, the patterns, and the colors accordingly. Like in the last few years, fine checkered prints, florals, and light shades have taken a front seat. In some regions, even the baggie shirt is slight, coming into the mainstream from the retro look.

But for most men, a shirt is a classic, all-time fashion statement that they wear typically on special events mostly or to impress the masses. Thus, they don’t experiment much with it, unless it is party time!

For men, a shirt is a shirt, if it has buttons running down the front, that’s it! So, then what actually is the difference between a button-up and a button-down shirt? Or is there really a huge fashion gap when it comes to button-up vs button-down? We take a deeper look, piece by piece, style by style. 

What is a Button-Up Shirt?

A button-up shirt or button-front shirt is that piece of clothing with a distinct neckline, a button-free collar, and a full-length opening at the front, which is secured by buttons. All shirts with buttons through their entire front are actually button-up dress shirts.

men Wearing Button-Up Shirt

What is a Button-Down Shirt? 

These are a finer version of button-down shirts, either through the entire front or halfway down, but the catch is that they have two buttons on the collar. In simple words, there are extra buttons to fasten the collar and keep it in place.

History of Button-Down Shirts

The historical backdrop of traditional shirts traces all the way back to 1869, in England. Polo players frequently found that when they were charging around the field on ponies, the necklines of their shirts would fold up in the breeze, and debilitate their vision. So they appended buttons to their collars, to hold them down for matches.

History of Button-Down(Polo) Shirts

It was John E. Streams who made the conservative button-up shirt a style thing. After watching a polo match in England, he returned to his American workplace and began fabricating them. Initially, these came to be known as polo neckline shirts. Quite soon the button-down shirt got into the realm of style and fashion, and as you can see these days, it is an exceptionally well-known thing we see today.

Also Read: Polo Shirt Outfits for Men

Styling Tips for Button-Up Shirts

Styling Tips for Button-Up Shirts

Button-up shirts offer versatile fashion options for men. For a classic office ensemble, pair with tailored trousers and dress shoes, ensuring a tidy tuck and belt. Opt for a more relaxed look by leaving it untucked with chinos and loafers. For casual outings, layer over a tee with jeans and sneakers. Elevate the attire for formal events with a suit and tie, adding a watch or cufflinks for sophistication. The Clasic button-up shirt effortlessly adapts to any occasion, whether it’s a business meeting or a dinner outing.

Also Read: Types of Ties That Men Should Wear To Look Impressive

Styling Tips for Button-Down Shirts

Button-down shirts provide easy styling for various occasions. Achieve a casual vibe by pairing it with jeans or shorts, rolling up the sleeves, and adding sneakers. Transition to smart-casual by tucking it into dress pants or chinos, complemented with loafers or brogues. Layer with a sweater or blazer for added flair. For formal gatherings, select a crisp button-down shirt with a suit, ensuring collar buttons are fastened for a polished look. Accessorize with a watch or tie clip for a finishing touch. Versatile and comfortable, collar-down shirts seamlessly blend casual and formal attire.

Also Read: What Color Shirts Wear With Gray Shorts

Caring for Your Button-Up and Button-Down Shirts

  • Follow Washing Instructions: Always check the care label for specific washing instructions. Generally, machine wash shirts in cold water on a gentle cycle to prevent shrinking and fading.
  • Proper Drying: Hang shirts to air dry whenever possible to avoid excessive heat and shrinking. If using a dryer, opt for a low heat setting and remove promptly to minimize wrinkles.
  • Ironing and Steaming: Iron shirts while they are slightly damp to ease the process and achieve a smoother finish. Alternatively, use a garment steamer to remove wrinkles without the need for ironing.
  • Storage: Store shirts on hangers to maintain their shape and prevent wrinkles. Avoid overcrowding in the closet to allow for proper air circulation.
  • Stain Removal: Treat stains promptly to prevent them from setting. Use appropriate stain removers or gentle detergents and avoid harsh scrubbing to preserve the fabric’s integrity.

The Bottom Line

One must focus on your overall style and persona, rather than digging around the difference between button-up and small button collar shirts. In short, rather than putting your brain much into button-up vs button-down for any occasion, focus on the shirt colors, overall style, accessories, men’s shoes, and totality of your outfit. And if you still need more tips, on how to style a button-up shirt or how to wear a button-down shirt, you can always write to us.


1. Is a button-down collar more formal?

A button-down collar actually becomes greatly informal if you team it up a suit and tie.

2. What do you call a button-down shirt?

Some people call them casual shirts, others call them buttoned-collar shirts. There is no particular name as such.

3. Are button-up shirts formal?

Oh, yes when teamed up with even trousers, they give you that crisp formal look.

4. Can I wear a tie with a button-down shirt?

This should be ideally avoided. But if you at all do, don’t fasten the collar buttons. 

5. If I’m not wearing a tie, do I have to leave the top buttons undone on a button-up shirt?

If you are wearing a suit, then the top buttons must be done. But if it is just a shirt-trouser or shirt-jeans pairing, then you can leave one top button open

6. Which is a more versatile shirt a button-up or a button-down shirt?

A button-up shirt is generally more versatile as it can be styled in various ways, including casual and formal settings, while a button-down shirt might lean more towards casual wear due to its collar style.

7. Are button-down shirts only for casual wear?

Button-down casual shirts can be worn for casual and semi-formal occasions, but they can also be dressed up for more formal events with the right accessories and styling.

8. What are some popular materials for button-up shirts?

Popular shirt fabrics for button-up shirts include cotton, linen, silk, and blends like cotton-polyester or cotton-spandex for added stretch and durability.

9. How do I prevent wrinkles in my button-up shirts?

To prevent wrinkles in button-up shirts, promptly hang them up after washing, use a steamer or iron on the appropriate setting, and store them on hangers rather than folded.

Related Posts